The Brewster Fish House

We recently visited Cape Cod for the first time and tried the chowder at this restaurant, which was truly exceptional. It was the best chowder I've ever had - rich, smooth, and full of flavor without being overly thick. The fish and chips were also excellent. Despite the busy atmosphere and our lack of reservation, we were able to find seats at the bar. The service was still good, and we had a great time chatting with the bartender. We enjoyed our experience so much that we are planning to return tonight!

We knew we were in for a good meal when we saw the parking lot was full and there was a wait to be seated at the restaurant. The hostess mentioned it would be an hour wait, but we were actually seated in about 30 minutes. While we waited, I grabbed our first round of drinks at the bar. Once seated, we quickly perused the menu and decided on a half dozen oysters and calamari to start. Both dishes were tasty. I opted for the seared tuna, while my wife went with the steak and frites, both of which were delicious. We were too full for dessert. Our server was attentive and the dining area, though small, was cozy and comfortable. Overall, it was a fantastic dining experience to cap off our last evening in Cape Cod.

I wish I could give the Brewster Fish House an extra half star for the quality of their food because 4 stars just doesn't seem adequate for this cozy and delightful restaurant. I have visited a few times and would come more frequently if it was easier to get a table. The fact that I continue to return is a testament to how much I enjoy it. On my most recent visit, I tried the lobster cavatappi with peas. The flavor was fantastic, although I do wish the portion had been larger and the price lower. At $46, it was a bit expensive. We also enjoyed the striped bass with cannellini beans and broccoli rabe, which was also delicious. I will definitely be back, hopefully sooner rather than later!

Stopped in for dinner on our first night of vacation. Had a fabulous meal. Thanks for the great time!

The bar tender was rude and the atmosphere was unfriendly. It is obvious that my criticism will have no effect because you are always so busy but I will never eat there again and will always discourage my friends from eating there. It is a shame because years ago it was my favorite restaurant on the Cape but something has changed. The attitude is not welcoming to the point that I wonder why you continue to stay in business.