Toppers Pizza - Appleton

Pretty much the perfect blend of taste and cost. Order is right 98% of time. Don’t charge you for little things like they do at other pizza places. Staff is super friendly. Parking is a little tight though

The food is consistently delicious, and ordering online through their website offers great deals. The only reason I didn’t give a full five stars is that I opted for curbside pickup and waited in my car on College for 10 minutes. Eventually, I had to go inside where I found my pizza was already ready—I could even see it from outside on their order screen. However, no one inside seemed to be making an effort to bring it out to me. I recommend avoiding curbside pickup, as I’ve experienced the same issue on two occasions. [Edit] There are no clear instructions about calling upon arrival, nor does it specify that curbside pickup is only valid in the three spots in front of the restaurant, which are not exclusively reserved for Toppers. It’s a bit of a gamble if you can snag one of those spots.

The service is outstanding! The food is incredibly tasty! Everything is served super quickly! It's truly impressive!

Toppers is our go-to spot for late-night pizza when we visit! I was thrilled to find out they offer vegan options. I really appreciate that their menu clearly marks the vegan pizzas. They have vegan cheese and vegan chicken that taste amazing—almost like they don’t belong in the vegan pizza world! The vegan options are so delicious; they’re definitely a must-try!

Without a doubt, the best pizza in the city! The quality of the sauce and ingredients is unparalleled. Even when things don’t go as planned, Trevor goes above and beyond to resolve any issues, ensuring you feel valued as a customer. I highly recommend giving this place a try, or even another chance if you’ve had a less-than-perfect experience; I guarantee you won’t be disappointed! And by the way, they’re open late now, so you can enjoy a nightcap at the bar without worrying about going hungry afterward!