Newberry Sub Shop - Reviews

I enjoyed my conversation with the people working while I waited for my order. Very friendly and great food!

We are from wellsboro and spent a day in Williamsport. We had this on a list of places to try since it was recommended by friends. Did not disappoint. Very good...

Always a great idea to go to Newberry Subs! Cheesesteaks in the garden today for tge win! Friendly hard working staff is all you can want in a Pennsylvania neig...

The food was delicious, even the cookies and brownies.

Hometown hoagie charm. They make the fattest cheesesteaks here and the portions are huge. Argument for the best hoagie shop in williamsport area.

Wait was longer, but it was worth it. this place is such a hidden gem. not luxurious, but we got the food. the writer was also friendly. we sat outside when it...

Here on a random Sunday. we wanted to find a place to eat on Sunday, in an unknown area during the kovid, we have a chance. wow. what a jewel! we.

Great business. the first time here during the kovid and the service was great. fast huagies and curb-side collection. ordered her käsesteak in the garden.

Always a great idea to go to newberry subs! ham cheese cosmo beats it! friendly hardworking staff is all they want in a pennsylvania quarter!

The personal is friendly. the it area is small, but very clean. eating was amazing whenever we are in williamsport, we make it a point to go there.

The cheesesteak and ham cosmo at this restaurant are exceptional. They are consistently phenomenal and are considered the best in Williamsport.

We always enjoy the food whenever we order from Newberry Subs!

Absolutely outstanding as always. the best subs in this town!

The bread at Cosmo was not toasted.

10 oz Half Cheese Steak (10 Oz Sirloin) was fantastic!

I want to eat one of their cheese steaks every day for the rest of my life. Amazing! Five of us went in after work out of town and they were just as friendly to...

Staff are friendly. The dining area is small but very clean. The food was amazing, whenever we are in Williamsport area we make it a point to go there.

I usually get the Philly cheese lg sub , which is big enough for 2 meals and it tastes amazing .. but I recently had the italian sub and it was just as good .....

Best cheese steaks in town, Not only great tasting but definitely a 'Bang ' for your buck!!

Excellent subs with friendly staff!! Unfortunately I went 3 times on my trip to the area and ordered subs that were supposed to be toasted. The first time I was...

Took over 40 minutes to get 1/2 cheesesteak and 1 regular hoagie. The hoagie had VERY minimal lettuce, tomato, and onion. Did not look like the hoagies they sho...

Ordered large (whole) sausage and 1/2 cheese steak was charged $26 there food is good but not that good.

Always a great idea to go to Newberry Subs! Ham cheese Cosmo hits it! Friendly hard working staff is all you can want in a Pennsylvania neighborhood!