Calissa Hamptons - WATER MILL

It’s the best. If you want seafood food cooked simply this is the place. Really good

Great atmosphere, fun place. The food and service were fantastic. A must go to spot in The Hamptons for food or drinks.

Went here during the Fourth of July 2024. Great place to go if you want to get roofied by one of the bouncers also who is also very old and creepy.

Worst place in the Hamptons to go out. Please don’t waste your time here. I got salmonella from my dinner as well.

The food was very disappointing, they didn't know how to make steaks, a couple of us ordered steaks, none of these were made properly. Mine was so overcooked that it tasted like rubber, and I had to send back and while the remake was better, still not great, and it was $78. For the price they charge, you'd think it's going to be somewhat decent. Gave it overall 3 stars since the manager was very nice and comped us some drinks. However, when we got drinks at the bar past 11p, they were way overpriced. Paid $64 for two drinks, $10 was “admin fee”, AND their cocktails are premade. The only reason I didn't give it two stars was because of the manager, but there are better places in the Hamptons like SouthHamptons social club than this one.