Peter's New York Pizzeria - Reviews

The best damn place to get calzones!! Keep it up Joe and Sal!!! Will never go any place else because you guys are the best!!

I had not visited this place in a long time because of some bad experiences I had with them in the past. Last night I stopped in to purchase a couple...

Great pizza and great service! This was our first visit to them and from the start it was great, the smell of the pizzeria pulls you in and entices...

Great customer service every time. Food is always delicious! Nice small town pizza shop!!

Been getting food from hear since early 90s, hands down the best pizza place around end of story

A hidden gem! I'm sure not sure I've had a better slice in NYC proper!

susie pizza tonight was amazing. the service was excellent and they were very friendly, talkative, and welcoming. the food was absolutely delightful!! best pizz...

Great food and customer service is wonderful. Went in late on a Sunday from a neighboring town since the local pizza place was closed already and loved the frie...

Came into restaurant based on others reviews on a little day with family. Could not have been happier. Food was great, service amazing. We will be back anytime...

Honestly some of the best garlic knots I've ever had, you can tell these guys know how to make New York style pizza and sides, wings were nice and crispy and th...