Osteria 57 - Reviews

it was great evening! great ambience, food and service!

Our service was okay. The food was alright. The music was very loud. I would choose another place next time. The staff seemed to be rushing to get us out but th...

Really liked my cocktail, and we got a nicer spot in the back where it felt more private. The food was good.

A wonderful choice for a casual meal. Food and service was outstanding. Generous portions.

Wonderful food noise level was almost painful. Would love to go again but probably won’t due EXTREME noise

I really enjoyed my cocktail, and we were seated in a cozy spot for two in the back of the restaurant, which felt more private. The food was tasty.

The menu at this restaurant was unique, offering delicious options for both vegetarians and fish lovers. The service was excellent, but the noise level was a bi...

I was greeted warmly as soon as I walked in the door. The staff, especially Anthony, was incredibly friendly and made me feel like I was visiting an old friend....

Wonderful atmosphere and fabulous food! This is a village favorite and we will return. We love introducing friends to this great find. Special was pasta with lo...

Waitress put in the wrong order for fish course which kind of ruined it for us. Bread average, octopus was delicious, pasta with porcini mushrooms excellent. Se...

Stumbled upon this restaurant and loved the food and service. Excellent!

I have to give this place five stars so I don't forget it when I come back.

The octopus pasta was perfect, everything about it just exactly right, please don't ever take that off the menu. The Lugana with that was heaven. Great, very kn...

Charming atmosphere. The staff were all super warm and welcoming. The food was beyond our expectation. Highly recommend the octopus as an appetizer as it was co...

Really excellent. Lovely service, delicious food. My only complaint: we were in one of the outdoor booths and the curtains don’t really keep the cold air out ve...

Great. We went here with my friend and tried the Restaurant week menu for lunch. Will be back for a date night. Worth trying!Food: 5/5

Sooo happy we got to try this place while visiting nyc! It was the best dinner experience two Italian waiters maybe owners ? greeted us warmly, chatted with us,...

You must have the Saffron pasta dish with the Foxy Lady! Absolutely perfect food and cocktails. Really made our anniversary date!Service: 5/5

Everything was amazing, but I definitely have to recommend the calamari and salmon!! Flavors and seasoning were spot on- nothing was crazy heavy or salty, which...

Excellent food and ambiance! Not one thing left on my plate. We had reservations for a party of seven, and we sat outside in what was made to look like little c...