Windamere - Reviews

My husband and I belong to Strongs Water Club and have eaten at Windamere two saturday evenings in a row. The food is delicious.Everything we have ordered so fa...

That was the worst eating in my life. jill was a great host, but the manager needs interpersonal skills. asking a customer “Well, why is this my problem!” good,...

Beautiful place, friendly service, live music. there are the 3 stars. Eating was just ok. hit or miss. the menu is very small. party of 4. the hummer cobb was g...

Unfortunately, none of the servers know how to put a smile in the face or interact with the customers. black cod was well seasoned, but undercooked. so it was n...

Really nice little lunch place. service with friendly and attentive. it is child-friendly and eating was great. I had a fantastic burger. prices are reasonable...

Delicious food exceptional service and wonderful atmosphere. I highly recommend Windermere especially if you're staying at Strong's Water Club Mattituck.

It started out with our table being served 4 cups of cold coffee, then we were given stale, possibly out of the box mini muffins. The main meals were just ok. M...

The staff Erin and Nicki were beyond helpful when I was there for a surprise engagement. I highly recommend this restaurant for friendly staff and wonderful atm...

Great staff, very welcoming and super accommodating. The view was great and the outdoor area was well-maintained and peaceful. Drinks were fun and delicious. As...

The space was welcoming and very clean. The servers were warm and friendly and offered suggestions. Food choices were limited, everything we ordered was good. T...

Very nice setting. Pleasant wait staff. 2 of the 4 meals were good. 1 fried chicken sandwich mediocre. Deep fried fish sandwich horrible. Ground fish and too mu...

Nice place, friendly service, live music. There are the 3 stars. Food was just ok. Hit or miss. The menu is very small. Party of 4?. The lobster Cobb was great...

We had a terrible experience at this restaurant. Three of us got diarrhea after eating there, and my husband warned me not to get seafood because he got sick fr...

I went to this restaurant with some friends on a Saturday and found it to be a very nice and clean place. Our server Kelly was excellent, and I particularly enj...

We recently celebrated a special occasion in the pool area and had a fantastic experience. The food was amazing, especially the duck wings, and the service was...