Goodfella's Brick Oven Pies - Reviews

I used to love this pizza place, but the new management has really changed things for the worse. The pizzas look cheap and almost frozen, with lower quality ing...

Guess this place is under new ownership. Menus is completely different. Employees were slow. Spent more time conversing than making orders.

They are understaffed, which is totally understandable in this day in age. The management needs to update the times it will take for an order to be ready when p...

One of my neighborhood favorites. They aren't great with customized toppings, so get a tried and true Smokin Goodfellas *chef's kiss*.

Great Pizza lots of choices and everything is made from scratch. They roast their own chicken and garlic etc..., make their own dough and pizza sauce. Good qual...

Stopped here for lunch. I ordered a small pizza with extra cheese and pepperoni. It was awesome! Great flavor. I'll definitely come here again, wish there was o...

I'm obsessed with Goodfellas. It's so nice to have a place with real ingredients used to make each pie. I ordered my usual pepperoni pizza and it was baked to p...

This afternoon was the first time I have ever eaten at GoodFella's and it was probably the best pizza I've ever had. I'll definitely be coming back. Plus the ma...

This used to be our favorite pizza spot. Unfortunately, There is a new owner. And sadly it has gone downhill. They have taken away all our favorite dessert pizz...

Discovered this place late in May '22 and immediately became my default pizza joint. Large pizzas were roughly $20.75 each, fantastic flavor and easily a 4.5+ s...

It used to be our favorite pizza spot. Unfortunately, there is a new owner. And unfortunately it went downhill. You have taken away all our favorite dessert piz...

Discovered this place late in May '22 and immediately became my standard pizza joint. Large pizzas were about $20.75 per, fantastic taste and easily a 4.5 star...

This glass of wine was $8.50 before tax, guys!!! Oh, my God! It is the cheapest tasting wine ever. What's going on? I've never betrayed myself like that before....

To the owner of Goodfellas. Do you know that your staff will clean the lobby an hour early and tell customers that they can sit in the lobby an hour before clos...

Went in to order two pizzas to-go. Total was $40.01 and the cashier would not spot the penny, but rather broke my third $20 bill into $19.99 in change. I guess...