Smith Wollensky - Broad Channel

Shrimp cocktail outstanding. Wedge salad unbelievable. Great sides and strawberry shortcake. Cajun ribeye top notch. I got the prime rib not so great. Waiter told me it is usually a tough piece of meat and to get it cooked a little more than I might otherwise. I should have just listened to him and picked something else. So tough it was very hard to chew and not very enjoyable. But again, the waiter warned me. I accept fault for that one. But I would go again.

EVERYTHING we ordered was amazing. Like everything. From the food to the wine, the app's, all of it. The only issue is we were sitting right near where the waiters bring the food out so it was a little disruptive but even with that it was worth it.

Daniel our server was spectacular!!! Food was fantastic, a delicious steak cooked to perfection followed by an outstanding spread of dessert! Would come back and bring everyone I know.

Great steaks and very helpful staff. Our table was a lot of work, so I have to commend them for all they did. Highly recommend.

This was my second time at Smith Wollensky. I had a better experience the first time. This time my steak was not cooked correctly. I asked for medium well they gave me medium rare and my steak was almost cold like it had been sitting waiting to get picked up for a while, my veggies was room temp or colder. I know they can do better because I have experienced it. Sighhhh I was disappointed and I'm not one to send food back. I never trust that.