Midtown Catch Seafood - Broad Channel

Our family has been getting fish from Mike for years. The fish is amazing, the service knowledgeable and friendly. And if you like creamed herring--and my father adores it--Mike's is heavenly!

I've been buying fish from Mike for thirty years after finding him at another neighborhood fish store. When it closed I was so happy that Mike found this location and opened his own store. I trust Mike. I know he only sells the best and most fresh fish. Never had a bad piece of fish from his store. I cook and I can always count on him. First quality! Not like Whole Foods that sells previously frozen fish. If you love fish, the minute you bite into previously frozen fish it's mealy and you know it. That's the difference that Midtown Catch makes in the culinary experience. Yeah you may pay a little more, but look at what you're getting: the BEST! I won't go anywhere else.

Just came across the shop and it’s wonderful! Mike the owner is super friendly and the fish is fresh. Cooked the scallops and baccalà we bought today

The fish is always fresh and Michael is very helpful and nice. I order for the holidays every year and he always has the best. His cooked fish, crab cakes and sauces are very good. I won't buy my fish anywhere else.

Twice I've shopped here, twice pleased! The fresh fish they carry may vary, but everything I've tried has been top quality, very fresh. Priced a bit higher than, say, Whole Foods, but way better fish. What I adore here, though, is the pickled herring in cream sauce. I've had Vita, I've had Acme, those jarred brands are good, but the herring from Midtown Catch is superlative! Have served it to discerning guests twice now, and everyone who likes creamed herring loved it!