Fisher Bay - Reviews

We had the fried catfish, caught locally in the Finger Lakes, and it was absolutely delicious. The shrimp were some of the best I've ever had as well. The fried...

We celebrated our parents' 55th Anniversary. It was a special day to remember.

I will never visit this restaurant again! It was a waste of money and the staff and management were very rude and disrespectful. I will not be dining here or at...

Great food! lorne and mary are great people and we go there once a week.

Had locally caught (fingerlakes) fried cash and it was out of this world, along with garneling some of the best I ever had. also the fried Schellfisch dinner wa...

First let me tell you this is a great spot. My friends and I are in town for a weekend getaway and this place did not let us down. Want wings? The mild/medium g...

Great place to eat!!! Great food!!! Awesome owners. They treat you like family.

Great food!!! Lorne and Mary are great people and we go there once a week. Service: Dine in

Had locally caught (fingerlakes) fried perch and it was out of this world, along with shrimp that was some of the best I’ve ever had. The fried haddock dinner w...

Food was good and plentiful. Waitstaff was friendly. Chef came by several times including bringing us a sample of an item we weren't sure about.

This restaurant has really declined in quality. I was very disappointed with the way things were managed during my second visit to eat here. No one in the resta...

I absolutely adore the Prime Rib Steaks at this restaurant and I miss them dearly. You can even drive your boat right up to the restaurant from Oneida Lake.

This restaurant is very welcoming and has delicious food. The beautiful lake view adds to the enjoyable dining experience. Just a heads up, the kitchen is only...

I ordered the large cut prime rib and it was cooked perfectly. For an appetizer, I had the shrimp cocktail. I will definitely be returning to this restaurant.

The atmosphere and service at this restaurant were friendly, the food was excellent, and the view of the lake was stunning.

The prices were higher due to the pandemic.

I recently tried the locally caught (from Finger Lakes) fried perch at this restaurant and it was absolutely amazing. The shrimp was also some of the best I hav...

An afternoon at Fisher Bay on New Year's Day was a delightful experience that we will always remember. The owners were warm and welcoming, and the pizza we trie...