Carney's Irish Pub And - Reviews

Thank you Johnny! We had a great girls night it wouldn’t have been as great without you! Thank you for everything!

We come to Long Island a couple of times a year and just found this place. Great food and even better service! Can't wait to come back.

I had the Shepherd's pie and mu husband, corned beef and cabbage. I loved my meal and my hubby said he finally found the restaurant that served a delicious corn...

Server was unbelievable friendly fun food was good atmosphere eh could use a spruce up overall nice time

Excellent food ,music and drink. Real Irish Pub. Irish fare and Pub comfort food.

What can say about the flavorless Shepard pie. Had no flavor what so ever, even with gravy and being cooked in the ground beef fat (hamburger meat, not real bee...

Great food very delicious, owner is very nice and so are the employees

They had a guy playing guitar he was good ,I'd go back Price per person: $10–20 Atmosphere: 4

Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Irish Egg Rolls

Price per person: $20–30 Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: Whiskey Wings, Shepherd's Pie, Scotch Egg, Irish Beef Stew

Great food and nice waiter. He was a younger guy. Live music was a nice treat. I'd recommend this place and loved the French onion soup

I was disappointed in the food. Thought they would have more authentic Irish dishes. Bar is limited with options and beer taps were dirty. Not sure why people l...

Went and had an appetizer platter. Mozzarella sticks were delicious and the pretzels were buttery in an amazing cheese dip. Irish music and Guinness. Cool place

Food is good Second time there, the first time they got everything we ordered wrong? The hostess saw it was so bad she comped us and pleaded with us to come bac...

Love sitting at the bar and having our meal there where we chat with the always friendly bartenders. If we meet friends there for dinner, then we choose a table...

I discovered this place during my day trip to Amityville, and it turned out to be a delightful surprise. The bartender/server was incredibly warm and welcoming,...

The food was fantastic, and the special wing sauce was among the best I've ever tasted. The pretzel was enormous—unlike any I’ve had before! I went for drinks a...

This place is a fun spot to enjoy drinks, whether during the day or at night. The few paintings I noticed were all of skilled bartenders, which added to the amb...

great food. great service. friendly staff. I broke into lunch. will definitely be back. carney sampler, desperate, quiet man sandwich everything delicious! the...

Came here a couple months ago, meant to leave a review and remembered just now. If anyone deserves a great review it is this place warmest staff I have met in a...

We had my fathers 80. Birthday with Carney's. Everyone from the owner, to the bartender to the servers were wonderful. Food and drinks were great. Loved the roo...

A taste of Irish heaven ! The food is very good and the service they go above and beyond !They are so friendly and accommodating! I had such a good time celebra...

The food was delicious, the specialty wing sauce was one of the best I've had and the pretzel was huge! Not like any other I've tried. Went for some drinks and...

Always loved the food at this place and the service is always great but my last visit the service was superb I had a new waitress named Lacy who is the best I'v...

I discovered this gem during my day trip to Amityville, and it was a delightful surprise. The bartender/server greeted me with warmth and friendliness, providin...