Buckatabon Tavern Supper Club - Reviews

Maybe it was a free day, but this place did not do it for me... salat had carrots that looked like they were freeze-dried. lettuce was beaten and confused. prim...

My wife and I are always looking for new places to try that have a quality Friday fish fry. we both haddock and were very satisfied. 3 piece with a subtle, but...

Today we had so much fun eating in our schnapps! natalie and james took care of us so well and eating was amazing! loved the cheese curds and deviled eier as st...

My mom heard the fish fry was good so we went mid afternoon. Place was empty but the music was loud and unpleasant. Our fish fry featured really greasy fish and...

Ate in their fun ice shanty my moms 85th birthday gift. We are from the Northwoods so it was great to be kind of back. James ,our server, was fantastic. Food, a...

The front door was left open on a chilly evening, which made me feel cold. However, the atmosphere was extremely enjoyable and cozy. The real surprise was the f...

We had a fantastic experience at Buckatabon! The service from our outstanding bartender, Alicia, was top-notch. She kept our drinks full, made sure our meal was...

Probably the worst restaurant I’ve ever been to. Service was extremely slow and food was horrible. In a party of 5 none of us were satisfied, four of us had the...

Great little place. Food portions are huge. Gluten, dairy, and peanut free options. Service is great, a large group may take time so plan ahead with reservation...

This place wasn’t bad at all its judged based on the night and the lack thereof with service because of the staffing. It was nice and the food was alright. Marg...

Cool venue with a nice cocktail selection and supper club style entrees. The pros: Old Fashioned was delicious Able to make reservations online The kids meal wa...

Fantastic Brunch, really loved the hunter hash! I would say that this is my favorite brunch in Milwaukee!

We rented a shanty today and it was an awesome experience! The atmosphere was cozy and unique, the food was delish and service was great! This is year 2 for my...

Love Buckatabon great experience every time! We had the shanty experience last night and it was perfect! The food was fantastic, as always. Service also fantast...

In short, made a reservation for a party of 8 for 8pm. Because of the time they ran out of the Cod. We all settled for the perch fish fry. The fish was fantasti...

I order a lot of vegetarian options on a menu and I'm usually disappointed. This was super super good!! The mushroom cream sauce made me want to lick my plate a...

An order of cornbread is apparently only one piece and it doesn't come with butter (the photo is deceiving). It was also dry and flavorless. The cup of soup was...

Haddock Fish fry was tasty but potato pancakes were overcooked and the batter on the Haddock was heavy and some what greasy. Cole slaw, apple sauce and tarter s...

Pretty disappointing. Odd taste. Very salty. Prime rib pieces had a lot of fat on them. The order was not good sized. It was a SMALL SUPPER CLUB NACHOS PRIME RI...

This food was so expensive and so terrible. I mean, so terrible. And soooo expensive. The fish was over breaded, over herbed, limp, and under cooked. The potato...

Everything was awesome Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5