Brothers Pizza Great Neck

One of the best independent pizza places around. Great food and the staff is on point with the service. Updated 4-29-22 brought my daughter and her friend again tonight around 5:20. We were seated by the bar in the left hand side. The young lady who took care of us did an amazing job. I wish I could remember her name. Truly outstanding restaurant and the staff is awesome.

I LOVE brothers pizza, but I LOVE it more than I used to now that they have this new bar tender. I think her name is Tania or Tonya, but either way she corrected my order that my server messed up. (I asked for buttered noodles with broccoli and got butter soup with no broccoli) she immediately took responsibility and it wasn't even her responsibility. It happened to be that the server rung my order in wrong. She was more than pleasant and made sure that I was comfortable waiting for my food to be remade. I honestly hope to see her every time I go in there. And just a heads up to anyone reading this, THE BOOZY WINGS ARE THE BEST IN TOWN!!!!!!!!!!! AND THEY WILL LET YOU ORDER ALL FLATS AND IF YOU ASK FOR EXTRA CRISPY, THEY GET IT RIGHT EVERY TIME!! EVEN TO GO, THE WINGS ARE CRISPY!

First off, I am not sure why people feel the need to rate negative experiences because it is a locally owned business and that really effects their livelihood. Everytime I go there they have great food and service. I live in between both of their locations so I go to both. Jason, one of the owners, runs both of the restaurants. He always checks on us to make sure everything is going well. They have an atmophere for everyone. When I have my kids they play on the game machines. When I don't have them I sit at the bar.

We ordered the Family Special (two large x1 topping pizzas, 50 wings with a two liter) and because there were 12 people, we ordered another 50 wings for pickup. This was perfect for our group, and the wing sauce (one order of Bros sauce and one boozy) was excellent. And the pick up time was less than we were told so that was nice. My only complaint was that I ordered a salad for myself, a Bros Banging Buffalo Chicken Salad. It was less than a handful of lettuce, two slices of green pepper, two slices of tomatoes, two of red onion rings, no croutons were on it although I didn 't ask for them to be left off, and a mild sauced chicken. I did ask for no blue cheese and extra cheddar cheese instead, which was accommodated. I didn 't look at the salad before leaving, but should have. It looked like the salad was left on a hot spot to keep things warm because the cheese had melted in the salad into a clump. Everyone in the group kept asking how the salad was, I could only reply, Sad. I have a pet duck, his salads that he eats on the daily are bigger than this was with way more veggies. And I don 't spend $13 for his like I did for mine. My fault I guess, maybe I should have looked at the salad before leaving the restaurant. But other than the salad, everything was good.

Let me start this off with saying, I’m only giving them two stars because I’d like them to be good again. We ordered an 18in pizza last night, we were told it would be 25 minutes until it was ready. We arrived about thirty minutes later. When we got there, there was no one at the register, customer or employee. We noticed a girl sitting a booth on the left on her phone, who looked at us then continued to sit there. A few minutes later she decided to get up to ring us out. Um ma’am I thought you were waiting for an order too, not an employee. Not just that the pizza is either under cooked or over cooked. This time it was over cooked and my dog even hesitated to eat the crust, when she did she struggle to even chew the small piece. We’ve been supporting this place for years, but we won’t be anymore. Also don’t look at the pizza oven if you go in there was like 2in of dust and crust in it.