Maguire's Bayfront - Reviews

They cut me and my boys off from the bread after like 6 loaves, but otherwise an incredible experience. Absolutely recommend you go here, just don’t ask for mor...

We ordered lobster roll, Bread was stale for lobster tasted sad, and Chewy. Definitely would not eat

The place is overpriced and overrated. The only good thing is the sunset but you can enjoy that from anywhere on the pier. The bread is raw cooked, waiters are...

Food is good but nothing memorable, definitely not worth the high price tag. Surcharges added for everything (e.g.; large group, splitting a dish). The entire s...

After having a very sad cocktail at Maguire’s, mind you…it was 1 cocktail on my first trip to Fire Island, I was handed my bill. I paid my bill and chose no tip...

If you come to Fire Island, you must visit this place. Always packed with fun people, great food drinks.. You will definitely enjoy your time. I have been comin...

Definitely enjoyed my first meal. The food was great paid with cash and was charged as surcharge which the waiter pocketed. I questioned them about it and they...