New York Pizzeria - Reviews

Great place but the pizza was like eating cardboard. Sorry but I gotta be honest.

Best Pizza in town !!!! Super friendly owner and staff definitely recommend!!!

Not worth the drive at all about one step up from a dandy pizza

Best pizza around, always try to grab a slice when in Tburg.

Worth driving out of your way on a perfect summer night to grab a pie.

I am from NYC and frequently lament the lack of decent pizza available in The Finger Lakes. I was so happy when I found this place. It is the closest I have com...

Love their pizza...It's the best in the Fingerlakes! Try it once and you'll agree Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30

You can't use canned vegetables for pizza. We ordered a tomato, spinach and fetta and half mushroom. Everything was canned. Worst pizza . Service: Take out Meal...

Worst slowest service ever. 40 minutes for a pizza. WTH?!?!? Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Service: 1 Recommended dishes: Large Pizza

Good food, but had previous issues with staff messing up orders Food: 5 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 3

Awesome Pizza friendly staff I mentioned great pizza

Best local pizza restaurant. Calzones are amazing as well.

Absolutely the best pizza you'll ever get in these parts!

Are you people ever open? If so Hope can you stay in business not answering your phone..???

I live in Ithaca, where there are several good pizzerias. Nevertheless, I often drive to Trumansburg to order pizza from New York's pizzeria as the quality of t...

If you are in Trumansburg and want pizza, this is the place to go. So delicious, other pizza doesn't really compare! Thin crust with quality sauce and cheese. A...

Pizza is absolutely delicious. Thank you for taking the time to do what I asked

This is hands down the best pizza in Trumansburg. The ingredients are so fresh and delicious. And the crust has great crisp. I'm normally the type of guy who do...

The best pizza in town, period. The cheese never slides off, the crust is never too thick, and the garlic is always pungent. The workers are usually nice and he...

First of all I usually have ranch with my pizza and they didn’t have any BUT I did not need it at all! This pizza is amazing! The sauce, the cheese and the doug...