Benny's Pizzeria - Reviews

First time there and definitely will go back. Everything was great ?

Great pizza and is great to have Benny's in the are when you need a last minute meal. Fresh Mozzarella is my favorite and would recommend it.

Absolutely delicious pizza and garlic knots, and friendly service. 10/10

I went to Benny's for years when I went to college in the area. They always had great crispy pizza with tons of toppings. I just went yesterday and was astounde...

We really enjoy the food. Just slightly disappointed the last time we ordered the calzones the crust was overcooked.. Otherwise we always enjoy the food..

The owner is in very bad taste, oh the man who served us was very rude and racist, and cold pizzas are not good, very bad and disappointing that there are peopl...

Today I went for some pieces of pizza, and the man who was serving me treated me very badly, I had to leave the pizzeria even though I was hungry but I'm not go...

Best pizza ever! Service: Dine in Meal type: Breakfast Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

I would go back this pizza and wigs where very good. Thank you.

Wanted to find something new after an away Field Hockey game. Definitely found the spot!! Walked into an amazing family atmosphere of warmness and positivity. T...

If there was a way to give negative stars, I would. It is a typical local pizzeria, EXCEPT the owner is stuck up, marginally racist towards people of color and...

HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE. We called to order at 7:02. Ordered an appetizer special, and a pizza wirh all pepperoni, half ricotta and meatball. Didn’t think this woul...

This place has the best pizza. It has been the better part of a decade since I have had this wonderful pizza. I moved out of the area but this used to be a norm...

I ordered a Turkey sub. On their website, it says all subs come with lettuce, tomato, onions, and your choice of dressing. I ordered via phone and the kid didn’...

I really like Benny's pizza. I work in Kingston and I live in Napanoch so I can call on the way home and it's ready just when I hit the halfway point. The only...

Tonight my team and I made a large order, and for the THIRD time in recent weeks, did not receive part of the order. And when I say large, it was almost $120. W...

Excellent Pizza!!! Wow. I had the basil pizza accompanied by the broccoli pizza. I also tried a garlic bread knot. Pizza was ready in minutes and was super fres...

This place is absolutely phenomenal. As a New York City foodie who cares a lot about pizza quality this place really holds the bar above all else. Super fresh i...

As you can see from the owner 's response to my original poor review of this place, he would rather threaten physical violence towards me and others, then respe...

High priced and additional fees for credit card....The food was ok and there was very little seating

6 months ago I am Native Little Italy and Bay Ridge Italian fella. I have blessed my whole life to have some of the best pizza in New York, just my apartment bu...

Best pizza I ever had! The crust was absolutely perfect crispy and chewing at the same time, the type of crust you leave on the plate. The toppings were plentif...

Late Night Sunday Pizza . Popped in Amd welcomes by the very helpful and competent team. Pizzas were huge. Calzone was huge. Chicken wings also delicious. 100 r...

I asked for Provolone to be added to my eggplant hero and it wasn't a problem. The sandwich was great it was large, really loaded with eggplant and the sauce wa...

Benny's Pizza is a little bit of a drive for me, but ALWAYS worth it. The food is ready on time absolutely outstanding. Benny himself is a phenomenal business m...