Magpye's Pizzeria - Reviews

Pizza was fantastic. Service was excellent. Only downfall was one check for the whole table. But since everything else was great. That was easy to over look. De...

Confederate Flag (as memorial) on gross display right by the front door; told us all we need to know and we won’t be back. It looks as if it could be removed fr...

Pizza was pretty good, not the best I’ve ever had but i certainly wasn’t disappointed. I was mostly impressed by the kind staff and great service. Our server le...

Can't beat the pizza for the price. Best on the peninsula.

The ladies there go above and beyond. We stop by anytime we are in the area. We were there Saturday, when we mentioned to the lady that we 'd be back the next d...

Great hometown pizza. I hope sterling builds up. 3 carries a large supplement. pizza and service is good. I had some resistance istdues, but overall I would lik...

My favourite place to have a cold beer and pizza! always good service and firma. it will stay my favorite place to not doubt relax!

Exceptional tasty meals... and if that's not enough, you will also get the best bang for the buck! I guess it's phenomenal.

This place was amazing. when they are in town, they should stop eating. we had an excellent buffalo flowers as an appetizer. I ordered a Greek salad. in the des...

Everything at Magpie’s is made with love and tastes amazing! Maggie and her family take care of everyone like their own and are quite welcoming to any and all p...

Whether you go through or a local to the peninsula, LITERALLY is the best pizza on the Kenai. It is worth at least one stop, but if you try it once, you want to...

My family and I love coming here! We are always treated as a family! The pizza is excellent! Love the crust, even! If we have family in town, we try to bring th...

I love the setup and home like appearance of the restaurant. Unfortunately, the pizza was nothing special. The bread crust on my pizza was done well and very go...

Great pizza, good salad, good beer. the service was good. We went for lunch, so it wasn't super busy. we will definitely go back.

Absolutely the best. They made my father a monument in the law and it was amazing. Food, kindness and friendship was amazing. R.I.P. Frenchie... you really knew...

Best pizza EVER. I Love their Stombolies. Everyone is friendly, atmosphere is like a neighbor hang out where everyone meets to visit and check in with each othe...

Great pizza!