Sweet Tomato's - Reviews

Three nights on Shelter Island and we stumbled upon Sweet Tomato's the first night. Despite the fact that we had planned to dine-around.... we ate there every n...

The service was great but there seems to be a downgrade on food quality unlike in the past. Pizza was dry. Salad was a little overdressed, and tasted more like...

If seated along the perimeter walls, the architectural molding makes it impossible to get comfortable because the molding sticks in your back

Grab a table on the porch and enjoy a nice Italian inspired meal or pizza in the center of this tiny village. Inside is cozy and better for a chilly night. I ca...

Were seated promptly. Wait staff was very attentive. Food recommendations were perfect! Enjoyed our meals. Will definitely return.