Shelter Island House - Reviews

My partner and I stayed at this beautiful property last year and fell in love with the place. It 's now become our annual destination for my birthday weekend wi...

The room I booked was over 400 in October-I thought it would be worth it because of the advertised fire place. The fire place can’t be used-it does not have a g...

I’m almost ashamed to say that although I have lived most of my life on Long Island I had never visited Shelter Island before. To celebrate my birthday we went...

The Shelter Island House is beautiful! The front desk people are friendly, knowledgeable, helpful and professional. The hotel is walking distance to beautiful b...

Last minute stay for 2 nights room was great. People were so nice. Although the restaurant was closed they were very helpful. I definitely recommend.

Shelter Island House is beautiful! The reception is friendly, knowledgeable, helpful and professional. The hotel is walking to beautiful beaches and good food....

Last minute stay for 2 nights room was great. People were so nice. Although the restaurant was closed, they were very helpful. I definitely recommend.

Shelter Island House is a wonderful institution. The resort was conveniently located. Sunset Beach is within walking distance. The grounds of the resort are ver...

Amazing hotel, great service, beautiful rooms and accommodation. Breakfast was great and definitely recommended to stay here.

I really only went to the restaurant, 18 Bay. Did not check out the rooms. 18 Bay is STILL my favorite place to dine!