Fritzsche's Bakery - Reviews

A hidden gem amongst the Sayville main St. Everything is so fresh and yummy. I go for the rye bread, and on Sundays, some cookies for company. There’s a front a...

A hidden gem amongst the Sayville main St. Everything is so fresh and yummy. I go for the rye bread, and on Sundays, some cookies for company. There’s a front a...

This is a tiny bakery that you may miss as you drive by. Even the inside is deceiving. Although, IT IS Actually NOT A SMALL BAKERY! The back area where the bake...

Visiting my hometown of Sayville. Ordered a variety of different bakery goods. All were so compromised in quality ingredients. It’s too bad.

This is what you call an old-school Bakery I've been to at least 50 bakeries out here trying to find cookies that had the taste of when I was a kid I knew there...

Lovely people at the front and incredibly high quality baked goods! The fruit danishes and nut pastries are fantastic. They have a wide array of desserts, and a...

My first time there I was looking for a cheesecake for my wife. The girl in the store that helped me was very nice and helpful. Everyone loved the cake at her p...

I'm new to the city and I was happy to find a bakery right in the village. So far I ordered two cakes and a few breads. Everybody was great. I love the Pumperni...

What a funny bakery! I had my granddaughter with me and she got a free cookie. The baked goods are wonderful. Love their donuts and their breads. A little jewel...

Applestrudel and cookies were fresh and delicious! Go back! Service was also super nice!