Caragiulo's Italian American Food - Reviews

This place is quality over quantity. The ingredients for everything we had were fresh and delicious. The chicken parmigiana was great – easy to put on the sauce...

Really good experience here. We had reservations, so we were able to show up and get seated almost immediately. The food here was absolutely PHENOMENAL! We had...

We received a recommendation to come here from a friend, saying this was her favorite Italian restaurant in Sarasota. She was right. This place is definitely on...

Food was excellent. Everything is fresh! Plenty of outdoor seating and service was very good. Our waitress Elisabeth who was originally from NY like us was grea...

We met a friend here. It's a stalwart in SRQ. We always sit in the bar area. The food is consistent, tasty and very cheap. Many regular customers. The place is...

Pancetta wrapping was left on a few bites of the Amatriana. It was very tasty. Pizza Davinci was excellent. Prices very reasonable for the location. We will def...

Food, service, and atmosphere were all top notch. There's a plethora of Italian dining options in downtown Sarasota and I feel like we got the best value for th...

Food is good. Good prices. The service : excellent Tha place is familiar The ambient is intimate

We very much enjoyed the food and atmosphere at Caragiulo's. I ordered the ‘eggplant parmesan al forno’, which is layers of eggplant, tomato, ricotta mozzarella...

Dinner was amazing. Our server who’s worked there for many years really catered to our 3 year old. It was a great experience!

Great find and very close to our hotel, the Aloft (350 yards). A nice casual Italian restaurant with great drinks, entrees, and pizza. Service was...

We had a great time at Caragiulos. I made a reservation over the phone a few weeks out for 7 people and it was no problem. It is so warm and inviting on the...

Love! Love! Love this restaurant! We just left this wonderful dining place! Delicious food, fabulous waiter and our home away from home in Sarasota! Thank...