St. James Pizza Pasta - Saint James

This place truly delivers! I tried the chicken parmigiana slice, and it was loaded with chicken from edge to edge. The sauce was bursting with flavor. Absolutely delicious!

"This is the best restaurant on Long Island! The food deserves a perfect score of 5, the service is outstanding and also rates a 5, and the atmosphere is amazing – it definitely gets another 5!"

We visited for four slices of pizza and two drinks, and our bill was $24! Unfortunately, the pizza didn’t justify the high cost. My two slices were doughy and undercooked, while the other two were dry, lacking both cheese and flavor. It seemed like there were too many young staff members who were more focused on their phones than on serving customers. Additionally, parking was a significant hassle. The previous restaurant at this location was much better and had more reasonable prices. Unless you enjoy paying a premium for mediocre pizza, I would suggest avoiding this place! Parking: Very difficult.

Although I believe the pizza itself is good, I can't justify waiting that long again, especially given the poor customer service. Unfortunately, I won't be ordering from them again, as this level of service is simply unacceptable.

I absolutely love their pizza, especially the upside-down Sicilian, which brings back memories of my favorite pizza from Queens! The crust is fantastic, and the delivery service is both friendly and quick.