Carmelas Pizza Italian - Reviews

We went out for meals our entire work stay. The food is delicious and Kelly does a great job, she is quick and personable. We will definitely come back here aga...

Waitress was great, Food was not what I asked for and then when I complained they remade it with the toppings I asked for. They just put the same steak on a new...

New to the Reidsville area from Texas. Ordered an extra large pepperoni. Not exactly what we are used to in size, this was smaller. But the pizza was absolutely...

Had dinner with my friend last night and I am VERY impressed. I LOVE Italian food, and I experienced the “small” Calzone which I could only eat half of because...

I live close by: this restaurant has rebounded significantly over the passed 2-3 years with excellent garlic knots paired with the $6 lasagna (it has ham strips...

I live close by: this restaurant has rebounded significantly over the passed 2-3 years with excellent garlic knots paired with the $6 lasagna (it has ham strips...

The food is right good. I enjoyed my pizza and my housemate enjoyed his calzone. The service is friendly but quite disorganized. That can easily be solved with...

Mine and my Fiance Cheryl's 1st trip was an awesome experience , our waitress Kalynne....was so sweet that although they left out an ingridient on my pizza you...

Great local place. Pizza was hot good, salad bar was fresh and the staff was friendly especially the young man that greeted us and stopped by to visit our table...

Great pizza. Papa John's, pizza hut, little Ceasars etc have drastically gone down hill in the last 39 years of my life just like most other places but on occas...

My second time getting food from here and it reminds me of when I lived in New York. The large calzone was amazing and worth the 15 dollars and my...

Arrived at 730pm thursday night not crowded at all 3 tables occupied. Waited on not quickly but good enough. Ordered 2 chicken Alfredo's( for 4...

The food was decent, but very oily. The flavor was average. I may visit again in the future, but not frequently. The interior decor is fantastic.

This was our 2ND visit to Carmela's, the first trip was so amazing! The food is delicious and the servers are attentive and quick. Both trips we got...

A to go salad is only $3.74 but there is the now a $5 minimum on Debit Cards, I was told to buy a soda to make it over $5, I DO NOT DRINK SODA!! and I...

This place is fantastic! My favorite dish is the baked spaghetti and the staff is great, especially Amanda! The spaghetti comes with a salad and two bread stick...

We've been here for a few years. New owners and new facilities. Good was very good. Servers we thought it was the only one to take orders to fix drinks, run the...

I was only here twice, but both times the food was delicious and the staff was fantastic. All the elements on the salad bar were super fresh, and their Italian...

I ordered lasagna and it was amazing the chicken parmesan my husband had ordered was also good. Our waitress did a great job! The costs are average for a sittin...

The pizza was awesome..the service was friendly..Highly recommend if you're in the area and want some good Italian food check out Carmelas Pizza

We get food from here all the time. Its always good. Im not one to leave reviews, but this Chicken Parmigiana was absolutely incredible

Everything was great! They have not failed me yet! This is my favorite restaurant by far here in Reidsville! Its always delivered hot and fresh! The Cheese Stea...

The food was absolutely delicious! I have never had manicotti or tiramisu before and was a GREAT experience! I will highly recommend.

This has been the first time we have ordered from Carmellas since we started using DoorDash over a year and a half ago. Our entire meal so far has been great! W...

Salad is absolutely disgusting. The lettuce is soaking wet and soggy, and the cucumbers are literally rotten. Worst salad Ive ever had!!