Margaritas Cafe Port Jefferson Station

Food was great. Best guacamole I have had in a long time. Made table side! Big portions. Lots of vegetarian options. Server could have been more attentive.Food: 5/5

I heard this place is good but no one picks up the phone and there's never availability to reserve online ahead of time. So what's the point. Very unfortunate. Really wanted to see what this place was like. Don't want to go without getting info before so we don't get turned away. Oh well.Service: 3/5

Just ehhh. The food wasn’t at all bad but it wasn’t spectacular. The place gives old vibes. Like it need updating. I more than likely will NOT be going there again.Food: 3/5

06/17/2023 Very nice place. Port Jefferson Station. Seated immediately. Appeared to be lots of staff. Live music. All staff was friendly and warm. Our waiter was extremely knowledgeable of menu. We were party of 4My Jambalaya was terrific. Saturday evening and we were able to relax no rushing. Will definitely return

Nice spot. Food was delicious, and house margarita was perfect. Friendly staff.