Captain Phantasy's Amici's Pizzeria - Reviews

The dining experience is consistently excellent and delicious. We have never been let down!

We are consistently pleased with our meals at this restaurant. The staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming, creating a family-like atmosphere that we adore.

Do not order from them, they overcharged me $36 and then told me to have a good day.

Okay, pizza. as ordered, hot and properly rubbed. expected fresh spinach, not chopped, cooked spinat. not pleasant. but many toppings! here is no joke!

Great place with great food. Definitely check it out!

Delicious homemade pizza vibes. Ingredients tasted fresh and the pie was amazing!Will be back many more times in the future, highly recommend trying this gem ou...

I've had almost every pizza offered in Port Charlotte and Punta Gorda. This might be my new favorite. I ordered online and the pizza was wonderful. Thin crust a...

Stopped in to have lunch and it's a takeout only. Instead of the pizza we ordered the foot subs: one chicken parm and a meatball sub. I had mine cut into quarte...

The White Pizza is to die for. Not on the regular menu, you need to call and order it.

Sorry, but this place is now terrible since changing to Captain Phantasy 's . My pizza was delivered literally ten minutes after ordering. Why is this bad? Beca...

Great service and the best New York New Jersey style pizza around

I've had almost every pizza offered in Port Charlotte and Punta Gorda. This is Amicis Pizza? I ordered online and the pizza was wonderful. Thin crust and cooked...

This has to be one of the worst pizza’s we’ve ever had. The crust, on the bottom was complete flour. The sauce had no flavor to it. The sausage was bland as wel...

Remember me coming home in Indiana! Great food, ground sausage is delicious

The only real pizza around. It is fantastic! Love the flavor of the crust the ingredients pops in your mouth. You can experience this special one of a kind plac...