Pizza Cottage - Reviews

I asked (in person) for my order extra pfefferoni and have made a little good. receipt said well done with three exclamation points, and not mentioned pfefferon...

We had a large party in the party rooms.Samantha was our server.She was fantastic. Service was fast and orders were all correct.She is very friendly, efficient...

Would rate a 0 if I could. So sad. Pizza cottage used to be one of my favorite places to eat. Unfortunately the service is horrible now. Stood waiting to be sea...

I came across Mrs patience Adamson when she appeared as a guest on a Forex Podcast in USA. I was listening to and was very impressed with her straight forward a...

First time there. Service was good, pizza was great. Mabie a little on the greasy side but still very good. Got pepperoni with extra cheese and Mexican pizza.

Went with a group in a private room. Service was outstanding considering there were 14 people. Food was served hot and fast, though a bit greasy for my taste, b...

Lately your business implemented AI to take phone orders. I am not totally opposed to this new innovation BUT I explicitly told the AI that I wanted a medium TH...

Always very friendly. Always good food. Love this place for lunch. Lunch special is a good deal.

Comfort foods, pizzas, salads. Pleasant servers. Indoor and outdoor patio seating.

8/6/2024 11:55 pm I was just bragging to my coworkers that this was the best pizza cottage in town by far and great pizza overall. We ordered a lrg pizza extra...

Type of Meal: Dinner Average Price per person: $20–30 Food Rating: 5 Service Rating: 5 Atmosphere Rating: 5 Recommended Dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Small Pizza Par...

The service at this restaurant was prompt and efficient. The food was incredibly tasty. We dined in for dinner and found the prices to be quite reasonable, rang...

The best white pizza in Pickerington is always delicious with chicken on top. It never comes out dry and is very tasty! The service is excellent when dining in,...

Stopped in to get take out and have a beer at the bar. Lisa came right over and was just delightful. I literally was finishing my first beer and she was already...

Every time we come home that's the first place we go, pizza there isn't anything better than pizza at the cottage. Parking: Lots of space for wheelchair Wheelch...

The garlic bread was mediocre, but the sauce was amazing and made it taste much better. The thin pizza I ordered was not very impressive, especially considering...

The pizzas at this restaurant are delicious with consistent toppings. However, there is a recurring issue with certain items. Despite paying $25 for a loaded po...

We went to this restaurant and the Alfredo pasta was amazing. The salad was lacking toppings and the pizza didn't have enough cheese or sauce. The service was g...

The pizza and ravioli were good. Very skimpy on meat sauce on ravioli, and they didnt give me my spaghetti.

I love their thin crust pizza. Especially their white pizza. I just wish Id actually get the marinara sauce side for the white pizza. Ive finally given up order...