Mary's Pizza Shack - Petaluma

Best Mary's Pizza Location. Down to earth. small old time location. They know when their dough is getting too old and not rising correctly. They always have nice large bubbles in their crust and their toppings go almost to the edge. Be sure to get the cheese all the way to the edge so it chars just a little. Be sure to request that they dry the mushrooms well. This location is better than N. McDowell: too pretentious, argues and disagrees when pizzas are not done right, cut haphazardly, too skimpy on toppings, sometimes they don't sweep the ovens often enough and you get soot all over the bottom of the crust, and lastly, their pizza maker has the pizza larger than the box...they just cram it in and shut the lid. Order all you pizza's from E. Washington!!!!!!!!!

Not expensive. Nice atmosphere. We're going back today. The service was a little slow, but that's not a fast food. We have the family shares. The second trip was even better. The insides of this restaurant are much better than you think it will be from outside. I add it to my regular list of places to eat.

I had my baby shower at Mary's on 3. December and then the 7th birthday party of my son on December 16. The staff was very friendly and helpful. The decor was clean and the food was so delicious. Malia was our server and was nothing less than AMAZING. She saw that I was overwhelmed and helped take responsibility. She remembered that I could have the He She Shot because it wouldn't spit my blood sugar like the pizza or the pasta. My family and I will definitely return to customers and recommend Mary's Pizza Shack to our friends and family.

I think it was the first day they opened when everything opened back up in California. Food was good. Service was great. We were the only customers for most of the time there. Looked like a lot of orders were for pick up. Look forward to going back next time I'm up there for work.

The last time I visited this restaurant was a few years ago with a family member who has since passed away. As a result, I felt a sense of sadness that lingered with me. I ordered the classic spaghetti with a large meatball from the lunch menu, which came with warm French bread and a delightful salad. The entire meal was fantastic. The waitress was very friendly and attentive, which made my experience much more enjoyable than when I first walked in.