Sal's New Classic Pizzeria - Reviews

new owner is top notch and the pizza is amazing! highly recommended!

New ownership has brought a breath of fresh air to this place. No offense to the old owner, but I was not a fan of his recipes. However, the new pizza recipes a...

Use to be good. Now there is never pizza out and last week I went pizza was under cooked and I got garlic knots and they put no garlic on them. I almost choked

Sal's cold cheese pizza is a MUST.If you go to Oneonta and miss this, you better not tell people you went to Oneonta.

I just got a 24 cut pizza for $28 half cheese half pepperoni. One of the worst pizzas I’ve ever had. I ordered from sal’s bc they were the only pizza place open...

We were in town for baseball tournament at Cooperstown. Stopped for lunch with the team and we were promptly taken care of and got our food fast. Pizza was hot...

Thankfully the place still looks almost the same on the inside as it did with the previous owners. Other than that everything has changed. I made the five star...

The best pizza we've had in a long time! the owner came and spoke to us and even gave our kiddos free dessert! The atmosphere was inviting, good music playing,...

Mediocre at best Hawaiian pizza…too skimpy on cheese and overcooked

HELLLLLLOO SALS PIZZA!! I'm from Ohio. My family always brags about this pizza!!! I finally had it!!!! OMG!! I NY PIZZA! Best Pizza I've had from NY! We will b...

The staff is very nice. However, I feel that the slices are overpriced and they don?t warm them up enough. I got a Buffalo chicken slice, the chicken was burnt...

Me and the family are up to drop our daughter off at SUNY Oneonta. We are from downstate and pizza to us is king. Sal?s was unbelievable. Thin crispy crust, Swe...

I was in town for a baseball tournament and just wanted to grab a couple slices, so I stopped in randomly. I was really surprised how good the pizza was. My wif...

Great Pizza. It had ziti on it which was cool. The guys behind counter were really nice. Highly recommend!!

I just got a 24 cut pizza for $28 half cheese half pepperoni. One of the worst pizzas I?ve ever had. I ordered from sal?s bc they were the only pizza place open...