Elmar's Ny Pizza - Reviews

Delicious. Don’t be fooled by how delicious the slices look, you only need one. Great lunch special. Parking is a nightmare because of how many retail spaces sh...

Best pizza in the cities, hands down. We drive from the east side for ElMar's. BBQ Chicken with jalapeños is our favorite, along with classic pepperoni. the wat...

Got the pepperoni/sausage slice for $6. True NY slice with savory cupped pepperoni and thinly sliced italian spiced sausage. Crust was nice n crispy since they...

I had been here before and it was pretty good, a tad greasy but that's what comes with pepperoni pizza. This time I got a slice of white pizza, my friend got ch...

Always love ElMar's! I saw someone post on social media that they were doing bagels and I popped in there at 7:30 AM on a Thursday and got two bacon, egg, and c...

True NY/Jersey pizza. I?ve been searching for pizza like ElMars for the last 7 years since moving from NJ this is it! Wonderful cheese, sauce and perfect dough....

Pizza was ready on time for pickup, and writing a review because it was so delicious pepperoni, sausage, garlic and oil. Generous amount of pizza, can serve a w...

A foodie account I follow on TikTok recommended this place, and it is well worth the drive. I like that you can order pizza by the slice or a whole pie. We trie...

This is hands-down the best NY pizza in the cities. This will go up in my top 5 favorite pizza spots ever. Staff was super friendly, place was very clean and ne...

I also learned about this place from Tiktok. My husband and I love NY style pizza so we decided to check it out! We have gotten it twice in 2 weeks despite it b...