Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza Pasta Mccordsville - Reviews

Carry out dinner. very good NY style Pizza. garlic butter toast was awful tho; Raul got us a store credit on those. will try again

Great lunch selections. Good service. Good drinks. It's definitely my go to place for lunch.

There is only one item on the menu that brings me joy and keeps me coming back here and it is The Goodfella pizza. Sausage, mozz, roasted peppers, sauce, fresh...

The last two visits I have had at this location has been fantastic. Laney the server is friendly personable and quick. Food is always delicious with big serving...

Carry out staff couldn’t locate order placed through their site online. I had to run home to grab my phone to show them proof the order had been placed and paid...

The owner and the staff are beyond nice and the food is amazing. Majority of the items are made from scratch in house and the calzone is worth coming back for e...

Just FYI they do not accept the coupon from Yelp. Our table ordered varies dishes: the fish, pizza, breadsticks, and pasta. Everyone enjoyed the food and the se...

If you like brick oven pizza then you have got to try the old world style pizza. My family loves the the plain with sauce and fresh mozzarella. The sauce is ama...

I LOVE GOODFELLA'S! My family and I usually get the smokin' hot goodfella's pizza and it is always AMAZING. I don't know what it is, but the sauce on that pizza...

My first time there I clicked on check in and got a messages for 20% off my first order. I showed it to the server who told me that wasn 't their store as we do...

Pizzas are great but I had a pasta meal that was not so great. It was actually down right gross. There were also gnats flying around my plate which was irritati...

Fantastic little local restaurant. I had pasta and a salad and my son had a kid's pizza. My kid loved the pizza and I thought the Caesar salad was excellent. Th...

Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Our dining experience was excellent! Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Italian Br...

I have given this place multiple chances during the last 4.5 years because their food is good. However, their customer service via both delivery AND pick-up is...