Papa Johns Pizza - Martinsburg

Best pizza around! Everyone should order Papa Johns

Always hot, always good! Great job guys! Delivered quickly on a Friday night and steaming when we opened the box.

Jamie sounded very helpful when I called but something went wrong in the follow through. I’m outside of the delivery area so I had to use Door Dash. I asked Jamie to help me get the crust I wanted since Door Dash didn’t provide an option, and Jamie assured me I could have the regular garlic crust instead of the thin crust his system defaulted to. I posted a 5-star review touting excellent service but am now changing it because I received a thin crust pizza with no flavor on the crust. I appreciate how nice Jamie was but am still disappointed because my husband only ate one slice and tossed the rest since it wasn’t a good crust. Jamie did send an extra garlic cup which was great. Next time I’ll order through Uber Eats or pickup.

I went here today and got a Italian pizza. I asked the cashier for the sizes if the pizza. He was very helpful in explaining the boxes to me. I ended up getting a medium because it was just me eating. The pizza turned out to taste really good. 5 star restaurant for sure!

Pizza has always been good and fresh. I pick up at the restaurant, so I can't comment on delivery. Price was good. I had the stuffed crust with pepperoni. Friendly service always.