Lyndhurst Pastry Shop

I grew up in Lyndhurst back in the 1970s and the Lyndhurst Pastry Shop is been a staple of the town for far longer. Everything they make is amazing, from the cookies to the fresh stuffed canolies. If you want fresh baked treats and friendly service then stop in and see what they have to offer. Also their Italian ices are worth a separate trip and they have a walk up window

My family and I have been going to Lyndhurst Pastry Shop since...forever. They do everything good. Plus they have the best Italian ice around. Great family business that has been around for so long for good reason. They are great at what they do.

My family has been getting cakes and pastries from this shop for decades. Everything is always fresh and delicious! We have gotten several cakes for parties that people still talk about years later. Wonderful pastries.

Very friendly establishment. A large assortment is available. Although there are better bakeries, there are none closer I can recommend to go. Service is great. The young ladies there are courteous and very helpful. I'm never disappointed. BTW... it also sells Italian Ices as well. One should not be disappointed. Can also get busy at times, which would lead one not to worry much about its goodies.

Amazing Italian ice and amazing ownership. I don't write reviews often, but felt like I needed to for this place. One of our family's favorite flavors was discontinued last year, and I got a call from Jerry (the owner) today saying that they have it back in stock-months later!! Their flavors can't be beat, and ownership like that just puts them over the top. Can't wait to be back!