Lenny's Pizza Bistro (aka Lenny's Of Jamesport) - Reviews

Pizza is great and the people are friendly. The chicken parm pizza was loaded with chicken and cheese. This is a great pizza place thats not know by many who ar...

Lenny's Is the BEST...!!! I live on Shelter Island there is no other Pizza Place Bistro on the East End that even remotely comes close... To the Quality, the Fl...

the food is good and the portions are big. they definitely need to remodel, its out dated, they have a nice bar but the waitress is an older woman so she doesnt...

Tonight we came across a really fine Italian restaurant and pizzeria. Ronnie our waitress was so amazing and helpful. She took great care of us and her service...

Cauliflower Crusted Pizza was PHENOMENAL!!! Even the kids loved it!!!! The wild mushroom slice was my go to but this blew my mind!!! Bravo Lenny!

Tonight we came over a really fine Italian restaurant and pizzeria. Ronnie, our waitress was so amazing and helpful. She took care of us and her service was gre...

So I was hoping to eat up to the bar in Lenny's and have a few drinks, but the dining room was closed on Tuesday. I decided to eat in the restaurant and I'm gla...

Excellent service, many menu options. The party of 11 served immediately, the food was hot and delicious. Don't let the pizza fool you. You have a great kitchen...

Good pizza, not great. Would go back. $36 for a cake with half onion and pepper seems excessive.

Lenny's Is the BEST...!!! I live on Shelter Island there is no other Pizza Place Bistro on the East End that even remotely comes close... To the Quality, the Fl...

Wheelchair accessibility: Easy access Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Recommended dishes: Pizza Recommendation for vegetarians Highl...

Best pizza I've had in 30 years. Service: Take out Meal type: Other Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Pizza

If you want a great slice of Sicilan (or whole pie) this IS the only place to go on the north fork of Long Island. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4

Do not sleep on this joint! Lenny is a legend and makes fantastic pizza. Super friendly, one slice is a MEAL! Loved stumbling across this place and I would high...

Atmosphere: 4

Recently, I needed help making the food selections for a gathering of approximately 20 people. Lenny had the most practical suggestions and the party was a succ...

I was staying at a local resort. Didn't feel like going out to one of the near by restaurants that we have eaten before many of times. So I looked up pizza in y...

Love this place! So friendly and welcoming, unlike other establishments nearby. Highly recommend!