Sexton's Pizza - Reviews

My official Facebook review is below..this is after my first visit. Needless to say I 'll be back: Finally decided to take a break from meal prep to indulge on...

Have been here before and enjoyed. Things have changed a bit you can 't order pizza by the slice after 3 or 4 o 'clock. My husband and I ordered the 16 half mus...

The photo 's looked great, and everyone was bookmarking it. When I knew I was going to be driving by, it suddenly became pizza night. Tucked in a strip center b...

Pizza was good and the homemade carrot cake was INSANE! From a local baker called Sugar Rush. YUM! The service and cleanliness was much to be desired. HORRIBLE...

One of the most awful restaurant experiences I 've had in the last couple of years. Important to note, this is only for the Reynoldsburg location the Gahanna lo...

I really enjoy this place. The pizza is probably my favorite in Columbus. Sadly, I called on 05/11/22 at 8:35pm and was told they were no longer taking orders f...

I live in Cleveland, but a friend told me to try the Kevin Bacon pizza when I was in town. It's a very good pizza.

The people were nice the chicken was good but, this pizza is not worth the price at all, it was very hard to chew, the top was kind of burnt as well overall wou...

First time eating here. The Kevin bacon was pretty dang good.

We have finally found our favorite pizza! The Kevin Bacon pizza is unbelievable. We tried it for the first AND second time this weekend! You can't go wrong with...