Peterson's - Reviews

we were for professional good with ease and genuine interest from the reservation through departure. I had the opportunity to watch the kitchen staff as well as...

Loved this restaurant! My husband and I went on Friday. Had the best meal. Loved the shrimp appetizer, only wish there were more than 4. Steak was to die for. E...

We had a very nice time and experience here. I don't say it lightly but this place is noticeably better than any of the other Indy steakhouses we have been to a...

First time there. First off was our “meal director “/waiter, Coy. He elevated the experience by his demeanor, finesse and giving suggestions that were spot on....

Great meal. We don’t eat meat. They ran out of the Salmon and Scallop specials . They were very accommodating since I was celebrating my birthday.

Peterson's provided an incredible dining experience, significantly enhanced by our exceptional waiter, Coy. The food was outstanding, and the wine selection was...

The food is fantastic—very flavorful and expertly prepared. I will definitely return!

I usually don't write reviews, but this was a memorable night. My wife and I celebrated our anniversary at this restaurant, and Coy Tipton provided us with exce...

We drove directly here from the airport to celebrate my birthday. First time in the city and at this restaurant. We loved it!! Wendy took great care of us throu...

Always delicious and great atmosphere. The bartenders are wonderful. Great recommendations and creative cocktails, along with good service. I know it will alway...

This steakhouse is top notch. Food, service, wine list are all fantastic.

Food was great! Best steak I’ve had in Indianapolis. Raw oysters were on point. Coy was our server and he was great. He’s been waiting tables for 45 years, so h...

Food and drinks were both 10/10, king crab Mac and cheese was to die for. The bartender shane recommended the espresso martini and it has beat every other one I...

Very nice place. Staff was kind and knowledgeable, and the food was excellent.

I.... speechless. Great everything. Every bite tasted great. Will be back.... next week. Oh, And the Crab Mac N Cheese!!!!!

We celebrated our 40th anniversary at this restaurant and had a fantastic experience. Our former classmate Coy Tipton provided exceptional service - he was kind...

I realize we were here for Devour Indy, But the salad was small as was the cheesecake. We were informed that we had received the last Tequila Mockingbird as the...

Excellent date night at Peterson's. Everything was great from the service from Coy, our server to the appetizers, to the entree, to the desert. Looking forward...

The food was excellent. We opted for the Devour Indy menu. It is important to note that this menu is specially created for Devour Indy, so the presentation was...

We had a wonderful meal at a corner booth table that was perfect for celebrating my birthday. Our waiter was excellent.

Seen this place a few times on my route at night… so I celebrated my girlfriend’s birthday here… we our server was great!!!… started off with a blue moon beer a...

After recently relocating to Carmel, we chose to visit Peterson's for some steak and seafood. From the moment we entered, we were greeted with warmth and hospit...

My main issue was with the pork chops; they were also sweet, despite my request to have the sauce on the side. I ended up sending them back, and then I tried th...

We celebrated our anniversary with a meal at this restaurant, and everything was delicious! While the lobster lady fingers weren't quite up to par, it didn't de...

The service at Peterson's is truly exceptional! It's an excellent spot to celebrate a birthday dinner. As soon as I stepped into the restaurant, I was welcomed...

My husband and I made a reservation for Wednesday evening to celebrate our wedding anniversary and his birthday. We had heard fantastic things about this restau...

Peterson's is a fantastic restaurant that serves high-quality food without any pretentiousness! We dine there 3 to 4 times a year, and each time, we are never l...