AJ's Oldtown Steakhouse Tavern - Reviews

Does that look like a $75 meal? I would give the steak a 7 out of 10, it's USDA primary, but we don't talk about Wagyu beef here! The scallops must be in water....

Absolutely wonderful! The staff has accommodated 15 of us and treated us with the best service! The dishes and cocktails were amazing! I'll drive from Anchorage...

The best restauran we been since we start our trip from Houston to Alaska we like local restaurants no chains on our trips as fish this is it mm. Thank.s!

Prime ribs were excellent, good for the price. Would highly recommend. Service was excellent.

AJ's steaks are second to none...period! You won't find a better steakhouse anywhere in Alaska.

Our tour guide didn’t prepare for dinner. We ended up wandering around town and happened upon AJ’s. Darryl was so accommodating, even though we didn’t have a re...

Amazing hospitality and first class service. The food was perfect, the beer excellent, and the staff were so welcoming and helpful. We called in without a reser...

My husband and I had a late dinner at AJ’s. We both ordered the New York strip steak; mine with goat butter and his with shrimp. We also ordered the Cesar salad...

Great dinner in a classic Homer. Favorite for tourists and locals. The place was packed and we didn't have a reservation. The host was SO kind and eventually go...

Food was mid range nothing great our waitress seemed not the friendliest service OK Pricey for what you get

The service good, food delicious. Music a little loud. Unfortunately they were out of the scallops calamari and our reservation was fairly early .

The food in Homer is consistently excellent. The service is good as well. This is not the place to go if you're in a rush, but it's worth it to relax and patien...

My $45 New York Steak Wed nite was very chewy hard to cut. Didn't seem like PRIME quality. Drinks, salad potatoes brussel sprouts were good though.

The food was delicious in general. Unfortunately, both of our steaks were overcooked. The wait for our main dishes was lengthy and the service was slow, so we d...

The food and atmosphere at this restaurant are excellent. The staff is very friendly and welcoming. It is the best place to eat in Homer.