Di Maggio's Pizzeria - Hicksville

This place never fails to impress. I have been ordering delivery from here for several years now and always have a great experience. Thank you to Dominick and the skilled delivery team for consistently providing excellent service.

New owners higher prices go without saying but the quality has gone down hill. We always loved their calzones. Tonight they were made by someone new, they were smaller, the dough stretched thinner, much more mozzarella vs the amount of ricotta AND the ricotta tastes different. We've been going here for years. I guess it's time to move on.

If you are in the Hicksville area this is a must stop for a great old school slice with a flair. Located in a unassuming shopping strip mall, this Pizzeria has it all. Once you walk through the doors you will see why this is a LI local Favorite. You will Start humming your favorite Billy Joel song because after all this was his favorite spot as a kid. On to the pizza?number one it?s always fresh you will never find pies laying around like other spots because the traffic is heavy and the turnover is fast. I had a Buffalo slice and as I said it had a twist?Sesame Seeds on the crust what a great surprise. It reminded me of so many great spots from my childhood in Brooklyn. I finished up with a ?Sal?s Sensational Italian Ice? incredible, I have not had an ice so good since Court Pastry Shop on Court Street in Brooklyn that has been doing it for 75 years?Sal and team have outdone themselves with Ices. This should be a destination spot for ices. Ralphs is like eating a cheeseburger compared to a steak you will get with Sal. Don?t hesitate call, drive, ride your bike or run?but whatever you do don?t miss out on a Sal?s Sensational Ice this summer.

Wow!! I haven't been here in years and I'll never go back! I ordered an order of Shrimp Fra Diavolo and a side of meatballs. What I received was an order of overcooked meatballs and a plate of pasta and tomato sauce. ZERO SHRIMP!!! $25 completely wasted. Biden inflation is one thing.. This was robbery! Side note :I had no idea this place was under new ownership, but seeing as how bad their service is, I don't see them lasting long.

Excellent New York style pizza with a great selection and some of the best crust I've ever had. Tastes like home. Very friendly staff and quick service too.