Water Street Pizzeria - Reviews

The pizza was good-sauce very good, cheese and pepperoni also good. But my issue was the CRUST. For me, it was not crispy enough and didn't taste like it was ma...

Came here for the first time for my husband's 40th birthday. Food was amazing and the staff was just awesome. It has a real down home feel. We will definitely b...

Called for a pizza during the Knights watch party. They said it'd be done in 30, which I don't know how they could get that magic done. Theres at least 2 thousa...

Well I have wrote 2 nice reviews and now this one is different. My mom ordered a pizza and asked if they delivered they said yes off our website. Well my mom is...

This pizza was sadly the worst pizza I've ever had. It reminded my partner and I exactly of those lunchables you can buy from the store that you squeeze the sau...

The pizza is great service was above average for sure!! Prices are reasonable will definitely be back

My friends and I just had lunch at the Water Street Pizzeria! There is no other word that comes to mind except FABULOUS!!! Several friends had pizza which was o...

Wonderful place quaint place. Reminds me of my dad's Italian place back in the 80's. Will need to return often. Love it

Great food and service. Limited seating if you plan on eating in. To go is a great option.

I haven't had this pizza in a couple of years now due to stomach issues. Ived been craving for it and we just have to have it for dinner. Still the best pizza f...

The Meatball Sandwich is excellent. Maybe next time I would ask for a little extra sauce, especially as the meatballs are huge! The simple chicken wings are sup...

I took my son to this place and he said it was his new favorite pizza spot. We love the service and the pizza. They give a family. Very friendly. We love this p...

Our sum was $100.00. Great order. The pizzas were ugly. Flavour shop bought, far away from fresh dough. The chicken wings were not delicious and too hot for mil...

I like this place, regardless of your personal opinions, whether we should, the pineapple pizza was delicious. It offers a good and cheap pizza in a world where...

We decided to try this place for dinner, and we were genuinely impressed. The people were welcoming, the place was cozy but clean, and the pizza was delicious!...

My nephew and I stopped in last week and were very happy with our experience. We ordered a Hawaiian pizza and a deep dish to go, plus mozzarella sticks and lemo...

Good pizza, probably the best in the area. I gave them a 4star rating because I don't really like their sauce much. The marinara provided w the garlic cheese br...

My husband and I had spaghetti and meatball and it was amazing! The sauce was the best I have had in a very long time! Also the buffalo wings were the best! Wil...

Awesome services and delicious pizza! My favorite one is pesto with pistachios..(see photo)

First time trying this place being a Chicago Native, and it’s really GOOD . Especially seeing that I don’t eat from authentic Pizzerias in the Henderson or Vega...

I love the spaghetti and meet ball Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5