Sid's All American - Reviews

I usually never leave bad reviews but this one it just ridiculous to me. Have to pay per topping making a 6$ burger into an 10$ burger for regular things like c...

Love Sid’s, for what it is. It’s a retro-y little burger stand with LOTS of milkshake options and pretty yummy burgers that are super straightforward and afford...

The burgers are delicious but super small. The drinks of all flavors are very good. Good place to have a good time.

First time at Sid’s. Food is good, customer service is awful. There is nothing more uncomfortable than walking into a place you are going to spend money with, a...

Kids adults enjoyed the frosted flake chicken tenders and thin fries. Thick crinkle sweet potato fries and alcoholic slushy were good. Next time will try one of...

Great Food, good for late night munchies, rlly good truffle fries, and great burger, good prices Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 5

Too expensive, they charge extra for lettuce on a burger Food: 5 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 3

Food is good and there is a nice menu with different options for shakes, fries, burgers. The location is small but it's cute, mostly pick up and outdoor tables...

Super friendly staff. Food is all made fresh. Food tasted great. Will be back. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4

Really good spot. Food was delicious and there are alot of options for toppings and such. Will definitely be returning in the near future. Meal type: Dinner Pri...

Sid's is an old school castle,ries and ice rink. The food and ice cream are excellent. The service is very good with young employees who pay attention to the ne...

Delicious, juicy burgers at a very reasonable price. The truffle friars are fingers licking well. Love the decor. But I often drove by and never noticed.

The food is great! It's our goal for a great burger. The service is always correct and they deliver! You are a real local business, you will not be disappointed...

Stops from Sid’s after a sunset in Bayville. Grabbed CheeseBurger and fries and ate back. Great food and fun atmosphere as a baseball game was on the field righ...

I love that they bring the food to your table! Everything was quite good.

Simply pulled into the area and it is so exciting to know we have a large Burger shop five minutes on the street. We got the cheese steaks with all the works an...

Great hole in the wall Burger square. The burgers are magnificent and the ambience is not good. Would you highly recommend swinging by and tasting your food!

Love this place! Best burgers ever. The menu is so great filled with many options!

Got there around 10ish after a long day and drive back into Long Island. The burgers were simple, but it hits the spot. The price is fair as well. The food came...

We like their burgers, Pommes and Shakes. Really good. From a childhood eaten by All American, this place could be sincerely beaten.