Payne's Custard And Coffee - Reviews

This place is a hidden treasure. After seeing the billboards for years I decided to stop on a rainy afternoon for a 2pm lunch. You feel like you're in Europe wh...

Absolutely unique experience. A little slice of Britain tucked into Indiana. Our server was incredibly knowledgeable and accommodating, as we had very little kn...

Wow! What a great find. Was driving to Indy and noticed a sign for Paynes, so I figured why not. Well that decision turned out to be an excellent one. The staff...

The atmosphere and the food were outstanding. Service was great! Our paranormal team (Cross Country Paranormal) ate here prior to our investigation at Old Black...

had the fish and chips. crispy, perfectly fried and very tasty. chips (fries) better than I expected, and many of them. sweet potato apple ingwer suppe inventiv...

The cod fish and spinach salad was shareable and delicious. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4 Recomme...

Food is always great, with good service. Vegetarian options: Eggplant Parmesan is fabulous Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 S...

I missed british food I was in England in June of 2023 and ate at this amazing restaurant much later the fish and chips tasted amazing so did the mushy peas, mu...

Had a pleasant surprise today when I found their food truck in Anderson. The fish was absolutely beautiful and oh so delicious! That crunch! Just perfect. Servi...

Perfect weather for dining on the heated porch. I had fish chips. My friend had a Reuben. It was delicious. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person:...

This restaurant is simply amazing! The staff is wonderful and the food is delicious. I will always make it a point to stop and eat here whenever I am on I-69.

After hearing positive reviews from others, we decided to stop by Payne's for lunch on our way back from the Michigan-Iowa football game. We were not disappoint...

This restaurant is fantastic. They serve authentic Fish & Chips and have a great selection of beers. The menu is unique and worth exploring. I highly recommend...