Secret Sandwich Society - Reviews

Amazing atmosphere, interesting and friendly staff, wonderful food. Our wait for a two top was 30 minutes, the hostess suggested to go to the bar upstairs to si...

Do not go dressed for imagination, go casual and ready to wait for sitting and be served. This special stop we came there at a busy time and had to wait half an...

To eat my favorite place in WV! The food is excellent and the staff is great! If you are in Fayetteville, visit Secret Sandwich Society! You may have to wait, b...

A must go to town. Great food and beer. Funny we are from Mount Wolf Pennsylvania and our waitress came from Hanover.

We love this place and never miss a chance to stop when we are traveling! The sandwiches are unique and the beer is always plentiful and cold. The service is al...

Sensational Sandwich and house made Potato chips My wife and I were recently in Fayetteville and were looking for a good place to eat after my Marathon Day...

I know things are very different now in this COVID19 world. But I was in the area, saw their sign and remembered I had friends who had checked in here on...

My husband and I stopped here on a chilly Saturday, around lunch time. We were seated on the enclosed porch which was heated but actually quite chilly. Most...