Vicini's New York City Pizzeria - Reviews

First time trying the pizza here. I asked how they got the pizza to really taste like NY pizza. The response? Attitude. Perfect answer. We tried the grandma piz...

5 stars for the experience dining in. Nothing beats having the pizza freshly served. What I couldn’t finish, I took home. Not at all the same, no matter what I...

Best New york style pizza your gonna find any where in the area. I had the pepperoni slice, cheese slice garlic knots, zeppeli doughnuts and got a calzone to go...

Calzones here are yummy. Pizza on the very thin side if you prefer think crust pizza

Small, NY style pizzeria. Very authentic and the pizza is amazing! Best in the area!

Great pizza! I love the garlic knots Calzone. A lil expensive for my taste, but you are clearly always quality.

Wow. Best authentic pizza!! I finally decided to order for pickup and this place is just yummy. We ordered the Margarita pizza. Fresh basil and tomatoes on top....

I bought the Daily Lunch Special for $8.99 2 Slices of Pizza a drink. The Pizza was a lot better than Evelyn's in my opinion. The Marinara Sauce is to die for !...

It is easy to find this pizzeria from Exit 48 of I80 Height. There are great pizzas and fast service. There is no flat dine-in food now, but there are two table...

Great New York style pizza. ? Arrived during lunch time. They have a lunch deal. 2 slices and a drink for $7.99. Not bad. Slices are big. I ordered a medium che...

This is the best pizza I have ever had. As someone who loves pizza and makes my own from scratch at home, I am often critical of other pizza places. However, th...

As someone who hails from the east coast, I can confidently say that this restaurant serves the best New York style pizza in town. In my opinion, the plain Our...

We ordered the Staten Island Garbage Pie Small, Vicini's Garlic Knots, Baked Ziti, and a Side of Meatballs (2). Even though our order took an hour and 25 minute...

Staten Staten Island Garbage Pie Large 18 Pizza and Our Famous Cheese Pie Large 18 Pizza are on point! best pizza around!

This is definitely my favorite pizza spot in the area. It was tough transition growing up in NJ only paying $20 for a pie to moving here and having to fork over...

I would give this restaurant 4 stars for the price. $60 for a large pizza, 5 knots, and 2 drinks is a bit expensive for me and my child. However, I would give 5...

I ordered takeout from this hotel restaurant a couple of times. The food was served quickly and was easy to pick up at the register. Despite the high number of...

We didn't receive the salad we ordered at Zero. We asked about the Caesar salad and were told it was good, so we decided to order one. We also requested an eggp...