Smitty's Italian Steakhouse - Reviews

I believe I have discovered a new favorite restaurant. Housed in a 100-year-old building, this place exudes old school charm. As you sit and listen for a moment...

The 12oz ribeye was delicious, but the garlic was extremely salty. The sautéed spinach was amazing. The baked spaghetti was a bit dry, but still tasty. The Capr...

Smitty's has really stepped up their game. The service has always been good, but previously it seemed like the kitchen was struggling. However, that was not the...

Omg!!! The steak was cooked to perfection. The pasta and bread pudding is to die for. Kate was the best waitress we've ever had. She never let the drinks run lo...

We had sandwiches-burger fish. Both good. My husband loved the bread pudding.

We were in town for business and Smitty's was recommended for dinner. It was fantastic! We started with calamari and bruschetta, both were delicious, the calama...

First time there, bit of a wait but well worth it!! Best steak I've had and the salmon was spot on had great flavor, service was excellent would highly recommen...

It was my first visit and it was the Best sirloin steak I 've ever eaten! I like mine 'well ' so I usually expect it to be a bit chewy but this steak just melte...

We have been here 5 times since moving to Evansville and couldn't be happier! Love this place. Never had a bad meal, service is fine and love that it's local. M...

The food was as good as it always has been, brought a friend too that had never eaten there, she was very impressed! Your Mascato wine was wonderful too

Having grown up in Evansville and now living in California, planning a party for 50-60 people can be challenging. However, I cannot recommend Smitty's highly en...

My family and I visited Smitty's Italian Steakhouse, an Italian steakhouse located on the west side of Evansville, Indiana.

We adore Smitty's for its nostalgic ambiance and lovely outdoor patio. The Chicken Florentine soup was simply outstanding. Both the chicken piccata and chicken...