Gills By The Bay - Reviews

Ordered shrimp cocktail, oyster shooter and 2 crab sandwiches (a hot cold). Everything was fantastic! I still don't know what crab sandwich I enjoyed more, both...

Cute little place on the bay. Hot, fresh fish cooked perfectly! My husband enjoyed the shrimp sandwich and onion rings. Excellent, friendly service! They were a...

Heard about a nice place to watch the bay and enjoy some good seafood. As a server it's hard eating out because you know what is going on behind the scenes but...

Best seafood place in town. And it's wonderful to sit outside on a nice day. Their crab benedict is the best but make sure you get there before 11:00 a.m. if yo...

Delicious!!! Best dining experience! Service had a warm welcoming and friendly feel to it. Attentive service, love the 50?s vibe! Will definitely be back next t...

Delicious!!! Best dining experience! Service had a warm welcoming and friendly feel to it. Attentive service, love the 50’s vibe! Will definitely be back next t...

I've been working in Arcata and been coming here before heading into town. The view is amazing and the staff is great as well. I've been getting different dishe...

Good food but can't say the same for service, had to call over twice so we can place out order yet there were people that arrived after us who were able to plac...

I ordered shrimp cocktail, an oyster shooter, and two crab sandwiches (one hot and one cold). Everything was fantastic! I can’t decide which crab sandwich I lik...

This charming little restaurant by the bay offers delicious, freshly cooked fish that is prepared to perfection! My husband loved the shrimp sandwich along with...