Cittanuova - Reviews

save you a trip! extremely disappointed and shocked at the terrible service we received last Saturday night. the waiter was the most rude we have ever experienc...

We had a group of 7 and they kept right up with us....never had to ask for waiter. Everyone's food was sooo good we looked more like a tasting table. Everyone w...

Lovely food and ambience. This time we really went for many dishes and my fav so far is the duck!

Very disappointing. After reading the reviews I was sure that I would have a great experience with delicious food. Although the waiter was very nice, the food w...

My neighboring town, an authentic Italian Restaurant that got a four-star just because I had to review a true international Five-star just before this. Fabulous...

Unfortunately I had to go with the rest of the 1 stars. I sat at the bar on a Thursday night and ordered a pasta and a side of Brussels sprouts. It took the kit...

I recently ate dinner in Cittanuova we were a party of three. This has been a go to restaurant for me for so many years, that I nearly forgot to post the 5 star...

Excellent calamari appetizers, great meatballs, eggplant, excellent friendly service. Can get a bit tight if you are seated near the bar, but the more the merri...

The food took a little while to come out, but it was authentic Italian cuisine, which was unexpected for this place. Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 3

This restaurant offers a great combination of indoor and outdoor dining. It has a sports bar ambiance but with a more upscale feel. The service is excellent and...

I had to ask three times to find my waiter during a Friday lunch. He never checked on me once. I still left a generous 20% tip. Unfortunately, the restaurant st...

I visited this restaurant a few days ago because it had the only available seat. It is a great restaurant with a wide variety of dishes and delicious food. The...

Charming Italian restaurant! Ideal spot for a lunch date. Be sure to try the margherita pizza and Caesar salad with their homemade dressing - delicious!

Delicious food! Beautiful scenery! Our waiter Scott was very attentive and kind. We will definitely be back!

Waited way too long for a sandwich ! 60 minutes! Waiter was inexperienced and inattentive which ruined our meal. Food good but the salad was a very small portio...

I recently had dinner at Cittanuova with two friends. This restaurant has been a favorite of mine for many years, and I almost forgot to leave the 5-star review...

Avoid this place! It's just a tourist trap in East Hampton that doesn't care about customer service at all. I waited what felt like an eternity to get a seat at...