Old Orchard Inn - EAST AURORA

We had the bridal shower of our daughter here and it was absolutely perfect! Eat. Service, drinks, atmosphere was very wonderful. 100% recommended!

Mother's day dinner. Very good! Lobster Gouda dip, chicken pot pie, manicotti. I would get a different dessert, but I took the gamble that I would like the bread pudding. I really should have gotten the creme brulee.

My husband and I were very disappointed in the dinner we had. First of all there were no options to choose a vegetable or a starch. The sides of the day is what came with the meal. So if you didn’t like what was offered, you were stuck with what accompanied every meal. My prime rib, while I know it can be fatty, was just that. Very unappetizing. And the way that some of the tables were arranged were too close to each other. The couple next to us were so close it felt like they were sitting at our table. We could hear their conversation and they could hear ours. It had been years since we had eaten at the Old Orchard. I doubt we’ll return. It certainly has gone downhill. Unfortunately we did not have a great experience that we had looked forward to. Vegetarian options: There were no options.

Go for breakfast. As down home tasty as you'll find within 30 miles

This place cares about your experience. This is a proper dining experience. Our waiter was fantastic, very knowledgeable, willing to go above and beyond, understood dining pacing. The food was amazing and well worth the price. My biggest compliment is how much they checked their ingredients for my life-threatening food allergy. This will be our anniversary restaurant every year from now on.