Coney Island - Reviews

Gyros were a hit. I was just passing through on the way to Silver Bay and made a quick stop based on a recommendation. Glad we stopped.

Super cute 1950’s atmosphere with nostalgic food coney dogs classic fries, you can’t go wrong! Shout out to Gary, Zach, Lucas Alan!

Coneys were great. Staff was very friendly! Lovely experience. Decor is a blast from the past! I'll be back....

Great coneys Gyros super fast service. Very clean establishment .

Not fancy, but definitely good! My parents and grandparents both ate at this establishment when they were dating, go for the special combos and enjoy!

Every time I go I demolish the gyro in minutes which is impressive for a twiggy girl with an otherwise small appetite. TLDR It’s amazing. Best tzatziki sauce I’...

I like the no-fuss service, excellent food, and the coolest looking interior design. The gyro was the star of the show, but if you want to spend less than $4 on...

This place is exceptional and goes beyond and beyond. There was even a time I needed a refill and milkshake and they let me swing around 830. These guys are the...

Great food and friendly staff. They have a simple menu of coneys and gyros. The fries are made fresh when you order. The old school diner is clean and fun—lots...

Best Coneys around. Husband loves his loaded coneys and I love their gyros and delicious soup. Oh course you can’t forget the malts and fries too. We have been...