Shy Simon's Pizza - Reviews

Great hometown feeling, the sausage, garlic, jalapeño pizza was so good!!! Our server was the sweetest most helpful person!! I will always eat there!!

Delicious pizza! If you’re going through Council it’s a must stop.

In my humble opinion, this is the best handmade pizza anywhere. Every time we head north and go through Council we stop at Shy Simon's.

Very rude customer service.. my order was forgotten about and brought to me cold..would never return or recommend to anyone... they have won awards by being the...

Shy Simon's is a local pizzeria. Of all the pizza I have had in many states I can easily say that Shy Simon's is the best.

Called ahead while we were traveling through town and ordered a Thai chicken pizza. We ended up with a delicious pizza and some delicious chocolate pudding. Wou...

We just enjoyed lunch out on the patio on a beautiful fall day in Council. The pizza is always great we had The Cluck sandwich, which was amazing. Service: Dine...

I found new pizza place and I love it there! Thai Chicken pizza was great and service as well. We'll be back soon ; Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per...

My all time favorite place to eat. Great sandwiches and pizza. The family that runs it is absolutely AMAZING! Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person...

Great place to grab a pizza on your way to or back from McCall. Service: Take out Food: 5 Service: 5

What a fabulously fantastic place to get some of the best pizza in the state!!! The staff is fun and friendly, with a lot going on and still smiling and laughin...

For a small town this restaurant has good food. My grandson wanted fettuccine and the first question I asked is the sauce homemade? The waiter replied yes, it i...

Great place to get a sandwich or order a yummy pizza. The restaurant is clean with friendly staff. Always a tasty meal whatever you fancy. It takes awhile 30 mi...

Consistently great food and always pleasant staff ... even their GF pizza is tasty! Add in a dog-friendly outdoor patio, a rotating selection of beer and you're...

I've been here exactly 4 times in the last few years. Once on a long trip around Idaho. Again just for the sandwich and to pick up a vehicle nearby. Two years l...