Casey's - Cortland

Grateful to have a fairly inexpensive gas station in town. Not a bad place to grab beer in a pinch as well (wish the latter were a bit more competitive in prices with grocer stories). Pretty good service.

Don't let these reviews deter you! I 8 months pregnant am in the caseys as I ordered online a pizza and would pay in store, the amazing gal greeted me with a welcome in and when all was done and I was paying she knew of a deal or coupon to help me save money! Which in itself is a beautiful thing! She spent the time trying to help and held the door open with my hands full and asked if I needed help getting to my car. Always love caseys and this is why!

Omg like for real. I look back in the line has 15 people waiting after 2x of using 2 different numbers. I turn and ask if anyone can put their reward number in because it keeps giving me an error. Well no one had a number so aibsaid forget it if you are going to charge me the full price for my drinks and not give me the sale prices because something is wrong. And she chose to say F you to a sale mind you where most item they were being bought were Casey brand items. All I wanted was my 2 waters for 3 something for the sale price putting my Casey number in. She could not over ride it. But makes a huge line loses a sale who knows maybe more some could have left seeing that line like really let's lose business but I am still getting paid my hourly or if that's not the case who cares I just lost the business a few bucks. It does not add up. Sad No one sees the bigger picture Well my kid and I will go somewhere else and never stop there for business.

It’s an older Casey’s, so the store is a little darker and feels dirtier. Also, it seems to be closed at random times that would be normal for a gas station to be open.

Better than dollar general in cortland and really nice employees! Really good pizza